In a very meta moment in X-Men Apocalypse, a group of young X-Men walk out of a screening of Return Of The Jedi (we are now in the 1980’s) discussing if Star Wars or Empire Strikes back is the better movie. Jean Grey (now played by Sophie Turner replacing Famke Janssen) ends the conversation “At Least We Can All Agree The Third One Is Always The Worst”. Probably intended as joke/stab at the woeful X-Men: The Last Stand (2006), it turns out to be even more meta than intended as the comment is also true of the movie in which they are in. X-Men Apocalypse is the third instalment of the rebooted X-Men franchise that began with X-Men: First Class in 2011 and by far the weakest.
For those that don’t remember X-Men came out in 2000, directed by Bryan Singer. By the standards of modern comic book movies it was relatively low budget, something that does show looking back now. It is a solid film with good characters, well cast. Singer followed it up three years later with X2, a bigger and better movie. Singer then made the unwise choice to walk away in favour of Superman Returns (2006) leaving Brett Ratner to make the aforementioned X-Men: The Last Stand (2006). Killing off a couple of main characters and possibly the franchise with it. The stand alone X-Men Origins: Wolverine (2009) did nothing to give any hope for the franchise. Then out of the blue Matthew Vaughn gave us X-Men: First Class, effectively an origin story. Written by Jane Goldman the film did everything you would expect from an X-Men movie and coupled it with a 1960’s setting. Set against the backdrop of the Cuban missile crisis it most of the setting. Bryan Singer then returned in 2014 with X-Men: Days of Future Past. Combining the cast of the original trilogy and the reboot, the film based on one of the comics most beloved stories. Possibly the best X-Men movie.
So where did they go wrong? The biggest problem with the film is the story. It loses most of its depth by not involving any of the politics of the time. The film also seems to be made up of just two parts, the first half the film is setup, the second a huge battle filled with colossal destruction. The problem could be the lack of Jane Goldman as a writer. The movie also suffers from a lack of a credible villain. While Apocalypse is often considered the great X-Men adversary in the comic books, he doesn’t translate well to the screen. His abilities seem to range from all-powerful to underwhelming from scene to scene. His motivation is never explained.
Then we come to the other misused characters. Cashing in on the popularity of Jennifer Lawrence, Mystique is set up as the franchises greatest hero, something akin to Wolverine in the original trilogy. She plays it with an unbelievably dour tone, think Katniss but blue. It made me miss Rebecca Romijn’s coldblooded killer interpretation of the character. They clearly didn’t know how to handle Evan Peters’ Quicksilver, so basically rehashed what we saw him do in Days Of Future Past, it isn’t bad but it gets tiered very quickly. Angel is better than in The Last Stand but still an ineffective screen character. Psylocke gets some good action scenes but mothering dramatic to do. Her costume is interesting. Where Bryan Singer has only ever hinted at the characters comic book looks, Psylocke is taken straight from the pages of a comic book, or at least a cosplay interpretation from a comic book convention. It isn’t necessary wrong, it is just distracting.
It isn’t all bad, Sophie Turner isn’t bad as Jean Grey but lacks both the depth and intensity of Famke Janssen. Tye Sheridan and Kodi Smit-McPhee are both good as Cyclops and Nightcrawler respectively. Alexandra Shipp is good as Storm but could have done with more to do.
Better than The Last Stand, but certainly the weakest of the prequels. The next X-Men movie is the as yet untitled Wolverine movie. Production started last month with a release date pencilled in for early next year. It will be the third Wolverine movie and potentially the last to star Hugh Jackman. Lets hope they buck the trend and the third one isn’t the worst!
Read Full Post »
It was a brave move for Marvel to reboot Daredevil as a TV show rather than a movie, but having just binge watched the second series it is increasingly looking like a good one. A few years ago the idea of a studio relegating one of its major properties to the small screen would have been unthinkable. The newly found status of TV helps but on its own isn’t enough for the gamble to pay off, the content has to be good too. A point proven by the fact that I gave up on Gotham and The Arrow after a few episodes each and haven’t seen any of the other DC, TV shows. The ongoing sagas of comic books do lend themselves to TV but there is something else. Daredevil is a better fit for TV than film. Where The Avengers work on a global scale Daredevil and his alter ego, Matt Murdock are firmly rooted in their Hell’s Kitchen home. This is problem that DC are going to have to contend with as they move Batman out of Gotham and into the world of the Justice League.
With a far darker tone than Agents of Shield and Agent Carter the series exists on the edge of the Marvel Cinematic Universe and is the better for it. The beauty of its execution, there is no need to see any other MCU property to make sense of it, and likewise, you don’t need to see it to complete the story told in the movies. Like the rest of the universe the odds have gone up as time has gone on. Although there hints a bigger story in season one, Wilson Fisk (Vincent D’Onofrio) was largely a local villain. Season two moves things onto a whole new level, introducing an outside threat. It is however careful with its introduction of new characters. Elektra Natchios (Elodie Yung) and Frank Castle aka The Punisher (Jon Bernthal) are the most notable additions.
We know that The Defenders is on its way, a new series where Daredevil will hook-up with Jessica Jones, Luke Cage and the yet to be introduced Iron Fist. To its credit, Daredevil resists the temptation of introducing the new characters. The only overlap being a cameo from Jeri Hogarth (Carrie-Anne Moss) from Jessica Jones and Rosario Dawson’s Claire Temple who has appeared in both shows. Elektra and The Punisher are better served than in any of their big screen outings with real motivations. The plot is well served giving character arc’s for all the main protagonists, both new and old. The new story both is tied up nicely and left open for future development.
TV will never replace cinema for me and I still expect to see the bigger stories on the big screen but some stories belong on TV, and good TV is better than second rate movies.
Read Full Post »
Posted in Comic Book Movies, tagged Earth-807128, Hugh Jackman, Hulkland, Mark Millar, Old Man Logan, Steve McNiven, The Dark Knight Returns, Wolverine, Wolverine Old Man Logan, X-Men on October 11, 2015|
3 Comments »
A few years ago I wrote about The Dark Knight Returns and how a previous Batman could return to reprise the role of batman. This type of role is unusual if not unique. Can you imagine an old superman or Spider-Man? But one other comic book character does have a literary source for an older version of the character coming out of retirement, Wolverine.
Wolverine: Old Man Logan was an eight-issue storyline from writer Mark Millar and artist Steve McNiven, published by between June 2008 and September 2009. Set in an alternate universe over fifty years in the future (designated as Earth-807128). A dystopian future where super heroes have been destroyed and the United States is divided five territories ruled by super villains. Logan, who has long since given up the Wolverine persona for reasons that become clear in flashback, lives in the territory known as “Hulkland”. The territory originally belonged to The Abomination and later conquered by the Hulk is now run by his the incestuous hillbilly grandchildren.
Hugh Jackman has hinted that Old Man Logan is the basis for the third and final Wolverine solo film, but has since suggested that this isn’t true. If true, this would leave the door open for Jackman to reprise the role for at least the next twenty years. It is common for actors to return to the parts that made them successful (Vin Diesel retuning to both Xander Cage and Riddick, Matt Damon coming back for a fourth The Bourne and Arnold Schwarzenegger returning to both The Terminator and Conan.), but it is rare for an opportunity to present itself so easily.
Jackman’s Wolverine has been a fans favourite since the first X Men movie fifteen years ago. As good as Jackman is, it isn’t all about him, Wolverine has always been a fans favourite in the comic books too. So as X-Men Apocalypse that he may or may not be in sees the end of a second trilogy, a reboot, or at least a recasting could be on the cards. Jackman will be a hard act to follow as he has become so iconic in the part (despite being a foot taller than the character in the comic books). The perfect time for Jackman to reprise his role would be after another character had either failed or had completed a successful run and everyone is debating who will take over the part.
This all assumes there will still be a market for comic book movies in a decade or more.
Read Full Post »
Three years ago I wrote about how licensing agreements will keep certain Marvel comic book characters our of the MCU (Marvel Cinematic Universe). I looked forward to the time when expiration of deals, lawsuits and mergers would start to brink characters back to the fold. The first of them appears to be Spider-Man. 19-year-old English actor Tom Holland who impressed in The Impossible (2012) has been cast as the new Peter Parker / Spider-Man. His first appearance will be in Captain America: Civil War next year before his 20th Birthday making him significantly younger that Tobey Maguire and Andrew Garfield (27 and 29 respectively when they first played the character). Significantly I understand this will not be an origin story. By the time we see him on screen Peter will have had already had an encounter with a radioactive spider, uncle Ben will be six feet under and Spider-Man will be a fully fledged (but teenage) crime fighter. He will then get his own film in 2017. The big question, should Spider-Man be in the MCU and potentially an Avenger? The way he has got there is a big of a mess, but unequivocally yes, Spider-Man should be there. But what, or should I say whose next?
A reboot of Fantastic Four is on the way in August, rights still with 20th Century Fox so still outside the MCU. The chances of some kind of crossover or team-up is certainly helped by the reboot, had they stuck with the original cast we would have the problem of Chris Evans appearance in both franchises. On the subject of casting, the new movie is full of promise; Miles Teller, Kate Mara, Michael B. Jordan, Jamie Bell and Toby Kebbell. The trailer makes it look darker than the first two lightweight movies, this will fit better with the direction The Avengers are heading.
Peggy Carter first appeared on screen in Captain America: The First Avenger played by Hayley Atwell. She has since made a successful move to the small screen in Agent Carter. Could a character go the other way? Daredevil has already appeared on a the big screen in the 2003 with Ben Affleck who has since made the big move to DC. Although a moderate success it received mixed reviews. I enjoyed it, however the TV show is considerably better. Already commissioned for a second series, it could work as a movie, I am not sure the very localised story will fit the vast canvas of The Avengers, but could see a cameo. Agents of S.H.I.E.L.D. started slowly but found its feet and benefitted from a change of direction thanks to the events of Captain America: Winter Soldier. A plotline that has been developing from the start has been revealed to be The Inhumans. This is going to develop further, It isn’t clear if this is going to be part of the current show, a spin-off or a movie. It would be good if they can find a standout character or two that can make the move to The Avengers.
I stand by my previous comments that although Wolverine, Sabretooth and Storm have all been Avengers in the comic books they don’t fit into the MCU, The Avengers would be obsolete in a world where the X-Men exist. It would also be difficult to introduce them now having never mentioned mutants before. Whatever happens and whoever they introduce the age old problem remains, there are too many men and not enough women.
Read Full Post »
Warner Bros./DC recently announced a list of random projects centred around the Justice League that should keep them busy for the next 100 years. Not to be outdone Marvel Studios have recently announced their Phase Three schedule covering films up to 2019. The films are:
- Avengers: Age of Ultron (2015)
- Ant-Man (2015)
- Doctor Strange (2016)
- Guardians of the Galaxy 2 (2017)
- Thor: Ragnarok (2017)
- Black Panther (2017)
- Avengers: Infinity War Part 1 (2018)
- Captain Marvel (2018)
- Inhumans (2018)
- Avengers: Infinity War Part 2 (2019)
When I first read the announcement it promised the a movie with a female lead as fans have been demanding. I had to go back to see what I had missed, a Black Widow movie? It appears not. Marvel Studios president Kevin Feige assures us we will be seeing a lot more of Natasha Romanoff / Black Widow (Scarlett Johansson) “Her part in Avengers: Age Of Ultron is very, very big and further develops her character”. But she is not the leading lady in question, that honour goes to Captain Marvel (2018), aka Carol Danvers. I skipped past the 2018 list assuming Captain Marvel was a man. It turns out he was, now she isn’t. Showing my ignorance of the Avengers comic book movies I had to look her/him/them up.
It appears the first Captain Marvel, created by Stan Lee and Gene Colan in 1967, was Captain Mar-Vell of the Kree Imperial Militia. Suggestions are that the Captain Marvel we are going to see will be the seventh incarnation of the character, Carol Danvers. First introduced as a US Air Force Security Chief, she gained super powers when her genes were fused with those of the Kree. She then became Ms. Marvel. More recently she took the title Captain Marvel. It is unlikely that Marvel will undertake such a convoluted origin story in the last twelve months of phase three suggesting she will join as an established character. Or more likely there will be a simplified origin that will take place in other films before she gets her own movie. Given the alien part of the story she could easily fit into Guardians of the Galaxy 2 (2017) or Thor: Ragnarok (2017). As an affiliate of US Air Force and S.H.I.E.L.D. she could fit into an Avengers story but it is unlikely that she will be in Age of Ultron unless they have kept it very quiet but may be Avengers: Infinity War Part 1 (2018).
The weight on the film is immense, not only does it need to succeed to prove Marvel can handle a female character, but it must also outdo Wonder Woman. The DC movie has a twelve month head start and a more recognisable character. This conversely could work in Marvels favour, it gives a slight release of pressure, in the same way that Guardians of the Galaxy had low expectations. Casting and direction are essential to make it work, there is no word on either yet, this doesn’t stop fan speculation or expectation. I don’t know anything about the character so would struggle to suggest who should play her, however as always I would like to see someone interesting and talented. The three names that spring to mind are: Emily Blunt, Jessica Chastain and Brit Marling. We will find out 2018.
Read Full Post »
Posted in Comic Book Movies, tagged 20th century fox, Anna Paquin, Ellen Page, Famke Janssen, Halle Berry, Jean Grey, Jennifer Lawrence, Kitty Pryde, Marie, Mystique, Ororo Munroe, Phoenix, Psylocke, Raven Darkholme, Rebecca Romijn, Rogue, Storm, The Wolverine, X Men Origins Wolverine, X-Force, X-Men, X-Men Apocalypse, X-Men Days of Future Past, X-Men The Last Stand, X-Men: First Class, X2 on September 14, 2014|
2 Comments »
When writing about a female led comic book/superhero movie I purposely missed out the X-Men. The X-Women are so complicated they need their own article. 20th Century Fox currently hold the rights to the X-Men. The film series so far consists of: X-Men (2000), X2 (2003), X-Men: The Last Stand (2006), X-Men Origins: Wolverine (2009), X-Men: First Class (2011), The Wolverine (2013) and X-Men: Days of Future Past (2014). The next film in the series will be X-Men: Apocalypse (2016) followed by an as yet untitled Wolverine sequel (2017). There has also been a suggestion of a spin-off X-Force movie.
The problem is twofold, the X-Men exist as a group or team and work best as such. The second problem, the X-Men haven’t always made best use of their female characters. In the comic books Wolverine has been truly successful as a solo character and in turn is the only one to get a his own movie. The one female character that could hold a film, Psylocke has never been properly introduced. The most notable character that advances have been disappointed with is Storm/Ororo Munroe. Many people blame Halle Berry for her performance, in reality it is more down to the writing.
Jean Grey / Phoenix (Famke Janssen) is better written for the screen but is used to the greatest effect when playing against Hugh Jackman’s Wolverine.
Marie / Rogue (Anna Paquin) has been used to less effect in each film until the most recent where she is reduced to a cameo.
Kitty Pryde (Ellen Page) Promoted from a cameo for to a leading role in Days of Future Past.
Raven Darkholme / Mystique could be the answer. Always an interesting character in the first three movies played by Rebecca Romijn, replaced by Jennifer Lawrence for the prequel movies, First Class and Days of Future Past, star power has been added to the mix. I suggested the possibility of a Mystique movie five years ago. I’m would have to be a different story to fit with the existing continuity but could still work.
I mentioned about the idea of an X-Force movie, this could do two things. Continue the old film series with some of the old characters alongside the First Class team. It also gives the chance to introduce unused characters or reintroduced characters that were wasted in The Last Stand such as Psylocke. Elizabeth “Betsy” Braddock/Psylocke first appeared in Captain Britain, vol. 1 #8 in 1976 as a supporting character to her brother Brian Braddock Captain Britain. Originally having precognitive abilities, then later revealed as a telepath, she also gained Jean Grey’s telekinesis ability. She later transferred into the body of female Japanese mutant ninja Kwannon. She gained Kwannon’s skills and elements of her personality. The Character has a lot of millage and could introduced in her Japanese form with an origin story to follow using an English actress.
I don’t see Fox rushing to join the race for a female comic book movie. But like the idea of an X-Force movie.
Read Full Post »
Posted in Comic Book Movies, tagged Amazing Spider-Man, Avengers Assemble, Avengers: Age of Ultron, Batman v Superman: Dawn of Justice, Black Cat, Black Widow, Captain America The Winter Soldier, Catwoman, DC Warner Bros, Disney owned Marvel Studios, Felicia Hardy, Felicity Jones, Female Comic Book Movie, Gal Gadot, Iron Man 2, Justice League, Lisa Joy Nolan, Lucy, Natasha Romanoff, Scarlett Johansson, Sony, Spider-Man, Spider-Woman, Wonder Woman on September 13, 2014|
Leave a Comment »
Ever since the explosion of comic book/superhero movies there has been calls for a female led movie. At times it has looked like no studio would take the chance on such a project, but there could now be a race to see who gets there first. There are three major players in comic book movies, the Disney owned Marvel Studios, DC/Warner Bros. and Sony who own the rights to Spider-Man (and many associated characters) thanks to license agreement between Marvel and Columbia (a subsidiary of Sony Pictures Entertainment).
Sony could be first out the blocks, it appears Amazing Spider-Man 3 has been pushed back and will follow a Sinister Six movie in 2016 and an female led spin-off possibly in 2017. Lisa Joy Nolan (Pushing Daisies, Burn Notice and the forthcoming Westworld) has been hired to write but no announcement has been made about who the main character will be. The most obvious options are Spider-Woman and Black Cat, the latter being the frontrunner as her alter ego, Felicia Hardy (Felicity Jones) was introduced in The Amazing Spider-Man 2. I know nothing about the character, a little research tells me she was introduced in Amazing Spider-Man No. 194 (1979) and has been both an adversary and love interest of Peter Parker/Spider-Man. I know about as much (or little) about Spider-Woman. It appears several woman took the name, most notably Jessica Drew, Julia Carpenter and Mattie Franklin. originally introduced in Marvel Spotlight #32 (Feb. 1977) she went on to have her own self-titled series (1978 – 1983).
DC have two options, Wonder Woman or Catwoman. A Catwoman movie is unlikely at this time thanks to the last attempt, Catwoman (2004). This leavers Wonder Woman. First appearing in All Star Comics #8 in December 1941, Wonder Woman is an Amazon warrior princess, known in her homeland as Princess Diana of Themyscira, she uses the pseudonym Diana Prince. She has a range of superhuman powers and an array of weapons as you would expect for a comic book hero. Gal Gadot has been cast to play the part in Batman v Superman: Dawn of Justice (set for release March 2016) with a possible Wonder Woman and Justice League movie to follow, no dates announced.
Marvel already have their character but don’t seem to know what to do with her: Natasha Romanoff / Black Widow made her first comic book appearance in Tales of Suspense #52 (April 1964). She was introduced into the current Marvel film universe in Iron Man 2 (2010) played by Scarlett Johansson, also appearing in Avengers Assemble (2012) and Captain America: The Winter Soldier (2014) and will appear in Avengers: Age of Ultron (2015). Little more than window dressing in Iron Man 2, she and Clint Barton / Hawkeye (Jeremy Renner) were the most interesting characters in Avengers Assemble and added a further dimension to the character in Captain America: The Winter Soldier this year. Anyone concerned about the star power of Scarlett Johansson should take a look at the numbers for Luc Besson’s Lucy.
Is it a question of who gets there first, or who gets it right? The success of the rubbish Transformers: Age of Extinction and the failure of the excellent Edge of Tomorrow there is more to success than quality. With budgets of up to $250million studios are more interested in fanatical success than art or critical acclaim. With this in mind, it isn’t a case of who has the best character, script or idea, but the one who thinks he can turn a profit. It might be a case of wait and see what the competition do.
Read Full Post »