Public Enemies has been out for a week now and has been reviewed may times over so I will keep mine relatively brief. First lets get one thing straight this is not a biographical film about John Dillinger. It is set in a very small space of time from shortly after John Dillinger’s (Johnny Depp) parole in 1933 (after spending eight and half years in prison) until his death in 1934. There is no back story other than a few pieces of information gleaned from conversations in the film. There are no early life scenes and there are no flashbacks. So if the film is not a biography what is it? I really don’t want to call it a satire but don’t think there is a better word for it. The film is an exploration of the myth and the iconic status of the depression era bank robber. The people time didn’t know who he was other than what they saw in the newsreels and in the papers and that what the film is all about. How the media created the myth and the man live/played upto it. The film explores themes often seen in other Michael Mann films most notably the likable sympatric criminal. He even gives Johny Depp the line “We’re here for the bank’s money not yours” previously spoken by Neil McCauley (Robert De Niro) in Heat.
So what we get is a film that jumps directly into the action of a prison break followed by a twelve month crime spree of robbing banks and living the high life constantly being pursued by the FBI. The agent in charge is Melvin Purvis (Christian Bale) a somewhat bumbling character lacking the charisma and panache of Dillinger although portrayed surprisingly sympathetically in this film. It is during this time that he meets Billie Frechette (Marion Cotillard) who is in some ways the best thing about the film. Although she isn’t given enough screen time to fully develop the character she does light up the screen with a performance that manages to be controlled and vivacious at the same time. Some of the other characters are underdeveloped as well but this isn’t a problem this is all Dillinger.
The music is brilliant, combining older music including Blind Willie Johnson and Billie Holiday with newer music such as the Otis Taylor track used on the trailer. Look out for Diana Krall as the nightclub singer singing Bye Bye Blackbird. This is all held together by a great score by Elliot Goldenthal. The production design is also first rate with fantastic sets, locations and costumes giving a real sumptuous feel to the film that is the perfect remedy for all the CGI rubbish that has been taking over our cinema screens all summer long. This brings me on to my only slight criticism. I am not convinced about is the use of digital video. It obviously has its uses and I am sure it is the future of filmmaking but it is a little clinical and lacking warmth when compared to celluloid. But if this is the price to pay for such a great film I for one can live with it.
In conclusion it isn’t the best film of the year so far but it is certainly the best film of the summer by a comfortable distance. With the new ten nomination system it should be a shoe in for a best picture nomination at the Oscars but it won’t win. But then I have low expectations of an academy that can give a best picture Oscar to Breaveheart and a nomination to a talking pig while Heat got nothing.
You have a nice site! Great information!
There’s a lot of mixed reaction to the digital video – myself I do really like the clinical look of the film (and it’s great to see a film maker advancing his style) but it’s the lack of focus when it comes to movement that scuppers it.
I really, really, want to like this film more because I’m sure the digital ‘issue’ killed it for me… looks like a re-review when it hits DVD is in order.
Not that I want to be picky…but a “twelve moth crime spree?”
That sounds like a movie i want to see ;P
It isn’t very good, the moths are nocturnal so only break into the banks at night so there isn’t much action!
I can’t believe I put all that thought and effort into a review and you pick me up on a typing error, not even a real spelling mistake (there will be lots of those if you look closely, my spelling is terrible).
Do you agree with my assessment of the film?
Awesome review… They need to make more movies like this one !!! I agree with you on the possible Oscar nod.
Sorry to upset you but the moth thing really made me laugh.
We’ve kind of already had this conversation on my post but I think we’re pretty like minded about the film, its not amazing but it is better than some critics are suggesting.
I really enjoyed it, but I don’t think its Oscar worthy.
Glad I amuse!
Oscar Worthy is an entire debate in itself. I am not naive enough to think that the nominations for the best picture are the five best films of the year (otherwise The Dark Knight would have received a nomination this year) or that the winner will be the best film but with ten nominations in the category next year it must be there unless there are lots of great films opening in the second half of the year.
[…] I made a plea for my local cinema to put something on for me to see as I hadn’t been since seeing Public Enemies two weeks ago. Although Harry Potter is still going strong in three screens and Bruno in another […]
[…] Public Enemies: Great story, great acting , great direction. It has its problems but is still a great film. […]